The Mets find themselves at a crossroads this offseason. After a 2025 campaign that ended in disappointment, the organization appears willing to entertain major changes — including making two established contributors, outfielder Brandon Nimmo and right-hander Kodai Senga, available for trade discussions.

1. Nimmo: A Fan Favorite Facing a New Chapter

Brandon Nimmo has been synonymous with the Mets’ outfield for a decade. But the club’s openness to dealing him signals a potential shift in direction. The key facts:

Nimmo is due to turn 33 next March and is in the midst of a large contract: eight years, $162 million, with about $101 million left.

He holds a full no-trade clause, meaning any move would require his consent.

His recent production remains solid — since the start of 2024 he’s slashed .244/.326/.418 with 48 homers and 52 doubles, wRC+ of 111. However, his defensive value has declined: once a capable center fielder, his metrics suggest he’s now more of a corner outfielder.

What this means:
Trading Nimmo would not just be about the numbers; it would represent a symbolic move. The Mets would be letting go of a player who has been a constant in Queens, perhaps to reset the outfield, adjust payroll, or open opportunities for younger players. But his contract and his no-trade clause make any deal complex.

2. Senga: High Upside, High Risk

Kodai Senga arrived with great promise, and when healthy, he has shown ace-level stuff. But his tenure has been marred by injuries and inconsistency, leading to speculation the Mets might move him. According to reporting, Senga is “extremely available.”

Key points:

Senga’s remaining deal: two years and $28 million guaranteed (with a club option for 2028) makes him a more trade-friendly contract than Nimmo’s.

His career MLB numbers: roughly a 3.00 ERA, 3.82 FIP, 26.8% strikeout rate — solid. But he also has an 11.1% walk rate and injury history that create concern.

In the 2025 season he began superbly (1.47 ERA in first 13 starts) but fell apart after a hamstring injury and posted a 5.90 ERA in his final nine starts before a demotion.

What this means:
If the Mets are serious about retooling or rebuilding the rotation, Senga may be one of the more trade-viable veterans. While the upside is attractive, the risk is real — and the Mets may prefer receiving value for him now rather than hoping for the old dominant version to return.

3. Why Now? The Organization’s Situation

The Mets missed the postseason again, and the 2025 team underperformed despite expectations.

With multiple key free agents (like Pete Alonso and Edwin Diaz) looming and large contracts on the books, the Mets may feel compelled to clear space or reset the timeline.

On the pitching side, the Mets are expected to add rather than simply subtract from the rotation, meaning they may need roster/money flexibility.

4. What Could a Trade Look Like?

For Nimmo:

Because of his huge contract and no-trade clause, any interested team would likely ask the Mets to absorb a sizable chunk of the remaining salary.

Potential fits: teams needing outfield depth and willing to take on some cost — though the Mets will likely avoid trading him to a direct division rival if possible.

For Senga:

A team needing affordable rotation help and comfortable with risk might bite. The Mets could get back a middle tier prospect(s) and perhaps a major-league piece.

The key for the Mets: get value now while the contract is relatively modest and the name still carries cachet.

5. Implications for the Future

If Nimmo departs, look for younger outfielders or internal promotions stepping in — potentially offering more athletic defense and lower cost.

If Senga moves, the Mets’ rotation could shift toward younger arms or external free-agent targets.

The message: the Mets appear ready to reshape the roster, balancing between staying competitive and controlling payroll/future flexibility.

6. For Fans, What to Watch

Will Nimmo accept a trade? His clause means he controls his destination, which could slow any deal.

Which prospect or asset would the Mets seek? The precise return will drive how far this moves the roster.

Will Senga rebound, or will the Mets cash him in? If he starts strong in Spring Training, maybe the Mets hold him; if not, his trade value may slip.

How aggressive will the Mets be on the free-agent market or internally? Trades open up options, but the next moves matter just as much.

—

Conclusion
For a franchise built to win now, the Mets are sending a clear signal: business will not continue as usual. Whether you love either of these players or cherish their past Mets moments, the possibility of seeing Brandon Nimmo or Kodai Senga in a different uniform is real — and significant. What the club does next will shape not only the 2026 squad, but perhaps the next era of Mets baseball.

Let’s gear up for unrest in Queens — and stay tuned as this offseason develops.