A Season of Turbulence and Glimpses of Potential
For Francisco Álvarez, the 2025 season was far from a smooth ride. It included injuries, a demotion to the minors, a strong bounce-back, and ultimately a test of both physical and mental resilience.
Early Setback: Hamate Fracture
The trouble began before the season even properly started. In March, Álvarez suffered a fractured hamate bone in his left hand, necessitating surgery and sidelining him for an estimated 6–8 weeks. That injury delayed his spring preparation, leaving him behind the curve as the season got underway.
Return to the Field & Mixed Results
By April 24, the Mets activated him off the injured list, and the following day he made his season debut. In that first game, he went 1-for-4 with a strikeout. Over the ensuing weeks, Álvarez had moments of promise, but also bouts of inconsistency. In 35 games before his demotion, he posted a .236 batting average with 3 home runs and 11 RBIs. Defensively, he too had struggles — the Mets’ staff believed in giving him time to sharpen his skills and confidence.
Demotion & Revival in Syracuse
On June 22, Álvarez was optioned to Triple-A Syracuse. The demotion represented a clear message: he needed to rebuild at a less pressured level.
In Syracuse, he responded well. Over 21 games, he hit .270 with 11 home runs and 24 RBIs. His defensive work, especially pitch framing and general handling, also got favorable reviews from coaches and staff.
Return & Further Injury Drama
On July 21, the Mets brought Álvarez back to the big league roster. Reuters+2Wikipedia+2 In that same night’s game, he went 2-for-4, doubled, and scored a tying run in a 7–5 win over the Angels. He looked like he was gaining momentum.
But August brought another setback. On August 19 (retroactive to August 18), Álvarez was placed on the 10-day injured list with a right thumb UCL sprain. He began a rehab assignment (starting August 27) and was eventually activated on September 5.
Performance Snapshot & Metrics
By season’s end, Álvarez’s stat line reflected both his high points and interruptions:
- Batting average: .257
- Home runs: 9
- RBIs: 28
- OPS: .772
From an advanced metrics perspective, Álvarez showed encouraging signs:
- He registered an average exit velocity of 93.3 mph, which is solid. baseballsavant.com
- His Barrel % (batted balls at ideal combinations of velocity + launch angle) was 11.7%. baseballsavant.com
- His Hard Hit % was notable among his contact quality metrics. baseballsavant.com
- His xwOBA (expected weighted on-base average) was .329 — suggesting that some of his outcomes may have underperformed what his contact quality merited. baseballsavant.com
These metrics hint that, when healthy, his raw tools (bat speed, contact quality, power potential) remain legitimate.
In terms of playing time, Fangraphs shows Álvarez appeared in 71 games with 299 plate appearances in 2025. FanGraphs Baseball
Highlights & Key Moments
- One of his most impactful moments came on September 20, when he hit a two-run double in the Mets’ comeback win over Washington. Reuters
- After his return from the injured list in September, he had a slow start (2-for-19, nine strikeouts), but then began to bounce back with hits in four of six games, including a home run. New York Post
- His August stretch before the injury was particularly strong: reports show he hit .341 with an OPS north of 1.000 in that window. New York Post+1
- Manager Carlos Mendoza and others praised Alvarez’s mental resolve — playing through discomfort, wearing protective splints, and focusing on what he could control. New York Post
Strengths, Challenges & The Road Ahead
Strengths Made Clear
- Tools intact: His raw metrics — exit velocity, barrel rates, hard-hit rate — show he still possesses the physical attributes to make loud contact and generate offense.
- Recovery aptitude: He didn’t collapse after being demoted. Instead, he attacked the assignment, performed well in Triple-A, and forced his way back.
- Intangibles: His willingness to play through pain, the mental mindset of resilience, and how he’s viewed by teammates/coaches all reinforce a belief in his upside.
Challenges That Remain
- Injury durability: Two different hand/arm injuries in one season (hamate fracture, thumb ligament) raise legitimate concerns about staying on the field and maintaining consistency.
- Offensive consistency: Outside of hot stretches, Álvarez had bouts of slumps, strikeouts, and offensive sag. Bridging those swings will be key.
- Defensive reliability: While his framing and handling showed improvement in the minors, his major league defensive lapses earlier in the season contributed to his demotion. Stability behind the plate is non-negotiable for a catcher.
- In-game adjustments: Facing elite pitching, the ability to adjust midgame — handling offspeed, shifting approach, situational hitting — will matter as pitchers do homework on him.
What 2025 Signals for His Future
The 2025 campaign will likely be viewed as a litmus test year. It confirmed that Álvarez can still do damage when healthy and focused. But it also underlined the volatility that comes with youth, injury history, and the high demands of the catcher position.
For the Mets, Álvarez remains a foundational piece — one they clearly believe in. But they’ll have to manage expectations, backs with depth (e.g. Luis Torrens, Hayden Senger), and ensure he isn’t overexposed to injury risk.
If Álvarez can string together a relatively clean, steady season in 2026 — healthy, consistent, making in-game adjustments — he could very well validate his status as a core piece for New York for years to come. But if the injuries continue or the volatility persists, the Mets might look more cautiously at alternatives or depth behind the plate.
Mets Junkies 
Leave a comment